The Antelope Valley Times

Your community. Your issues. Your news.

  • Home
  • Latest News
  • Local
    • Palmdale
    • Lancaster
    • Los Angeles County
    • Littlerock
    • Lake Los Angeles
    • Rosamond
    • Edwards AFB
    • Acton
  • Crime
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Health
  • Business
  • Opinion
    • Advertise
    • About
    • Contact Us
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    Show Search

Restaurant owners who challenged indoor dining ban drop legal action

by The AV Times Staff • January 29, 2022

Three owners of dine-in restaurants in Los Angeles County who filed a legal action demanding compensation for revenue losses when indoor dining was prohibited under coronavirus restrictions have dropped their case.

In their petition filed last April 12, petitioners James P. Trani, Steve Patrick and John Marvoich named as respondents the state of California and Los Angeles County. The three businessmen alleged the forced closures amounted to a government taking and violating their rights of free speech and assembly. Their court papers did not name the restaurants they own.

In October, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Jon R. Takasugi granted a motion by the Attorney General’s Office to dismiss the state as a party, saying the restaurant owners had “not submitted any facts which could show that state defendants commandeered or utilized any personal property. In fact, plaintiffs allege that they continued to operate their restaurants as take-out restaurants, albeit with less business.”

Two months later, the judge found the county was not properly served with the petition and quashed service. Then, on Thursday, Jan. 27, the restaurant owners’ lawyer, James Otto, filed court papers with the judge asking that the remainder of the case be dismissed. No reason was given for the businessmen’s’ decision.

According to the petition, the ban on indoor dining was “an irrational and unnecessary order to stop the spread of the COVID-19 virus by punishing the irrelevant plaintiffs who are virus-free and pose absolutely no risk of spreading the virus.” The restaurant owners maintained the shutdown was “not rationally related to a or any governmental interest as it was unsupported by any evidence and defined logic, nature, and/or common sense.”

Before the closures, Trani operated his restaurant at a profit for 30 years, while Marvoich’s eatery was in the black for 20 years and Patrick’s for 11 years, the petition stated. Their businesses have never been the source of the COVID-19 or any other virus, the petition stated.

–

Filed Under: Business, Health, Home, Los Angeles County

3 comments for "Restaurant owners who challenged indoor dining ban drop legal action"

  1. FWB says

    January 31, 2022 at 8:39 am

    Restaurant owners who do not push back do not get my business.

    • Tim Scott says

      January 31, 2022 at 12:41 pm

      Restaurant owners with a demonstrated lack of interest in maintaining public health should be out of business.

  2. Arthur Rubin says

    January 30, 2022 at 5:28 pm

    It may be not be legal grounds, but it is certainly true that the ban on indoor dining is not rationally related to any government interest.

    There seems to be no legal requirement that government actions be rationally related to any government interest.

Recent Comments

  • Tony on Man allegedly steals CHP vehicle, leaps from speeding cruiser: “I was laughing that they kept saying 70 pmh when it was actually 45 mph” Mar 29, 00:18
  • Tim Scott on Judge awards $1 million in attorneys’ fees to worker who protested segregation: ““Tim’s finally right about 1 thing, those were the good ol’ days” I can see why you would think of…” Mar 28, 23:54
  • Tim Scott on Man allegedly steals CHP vehicle, leaps from speeding cruiser: “True, but if you crack the door open before you let off the gas the momentum of the door as…” Mar 28, 23:22
  • Tim Scott on 15 arrested or cited, none for DUI at Palmdale checkpoint: “That’s why it begs the question; if they are really trying to catch drunk drivers, why is 2AM the shut…” Mar 28, 23:20
  • Ledesma 99 on Man allegedly steals CHP vehicle, leaps from speeding cruiser: “He must be Hercules. The aerodynamic drag against the door of a speeding vehicle is enormous.” Mar 28, 23:02

Copyright © 2023 · The AV Times LLC. All rights reserved. Terms of Use